I was way underwhelmed by Grand … Thanks for the excellent review of the new MoFi LP Reissue of Procol Harum's A Salty Dog. PROG REVIEWER. That album opened with Trower's unrelenting "Whisky Train," a blues-rock number that perhaps indicated where his heart was during the recording sessions. It also analyzes reviews to verify trustworthiness. _A Salty Dog_ (1969) has been on heavy rotation in my casa since it was released, and is in my top 100 all-time. The closing “Pilgrim’s Progress,” sung by Fisher, puts the spotlight where it belongs, on Keith Reid. Three contemporary reviews of the Salty Dog album: The 1997 Repertoire re-issue: Procol Harum's cover, itself a parody of the famous Player's Tobacco advert, spawned this parody in July 2001: Thanks to Matt Wosniak at The Unofficial Mutts Page: Order A Salty Dog ...plus! I loved this album so much when it came out in the 60s. Discover releases, reviews, credits, songs, and more about Procol Harum - A Salty Dog at Discogs. Even though "The Idol" is repetitive I've grown to … 17 is an adequate, 12-song retrospective of Procol Harum's biggest hits and best-known songs, featuring A Whiter Shade of Pale, Conquistador, A Salt Dog and Homburg. Your email address will not be published. It also found the band experimenting with different musical instruments: celeste, marimba, recorder, congas, tabla. There's a problem loading this menu right now. Released on elpee in May 1969 in the US and Canada (A&M, SP 4179) and Germany (Polydor, 184 221); reached #27 on the UK charts and #32 on the US charts. In Trower’s defense, “Too Much Between Us” is a song for the ages, and whatever his contributions were to the song, they have earned him some measure of immortality in my book. (Gary Booker – piano, three-stringed guitar, celeste, bells harmonica, recorder, word, vocals and orchestral arrangement (Salty Dog, All This And More); Matthew Fisher – producer, […] “Crucifiction Lane” is all right, but “Juicy John Pink” is the sort of track you expect to find tacked on to an expanded remaster, not smack in the middle of one of the greatest rock records of all time. Buying it and playing it again I am amazed at how much resonance it has for my way of life and admittedly more mature view of the world now I am a hell of a lot older. Reviewed in the United States on February 15, 2019, Unexpected additional disk, booklet and poster! harrythe3rd June 22, 2010 Report; My album also has SP 3132 on the front and spine, but SP 4179 on the back. One of the coolest album covers around is what originally prompted me to buy this album forty years ago and the quality of what's inside has kept me buying every "improvement" since then. The same year they released their self titled debut album. There are some real standouts like the title track and 'Wreck of the Hesperus', and some of the more light-hearted, kitschier tracks are considerably better … 14. After viewing product detail pages, look here to find an easy way to navigate back to pages you are interested in. The same year they released their self titled debut album. Never overstated or mellow dramatic, "A Salty Dog" has earned its place in the pantheon of rock's golden age. What sets Procol Harum and paticularly "A Salty Dog" apart is its subtelty. Fifty years ago, Procol Harum recorded one of the most ambitious rock records in history, A Salty Dog. 16. Download Pdf. Procol Harum started out as a psychedelic rock band, who gained fame with their single "A Whiter Shade of Pale" in 1967, which would eventually sell over 10 million copies. Boredom (Matthew Fisher/Gary Brooker/Keith Reid) Long Gone Geek Genres: Progressive Rock. Juicy John Pink (Robin Trower/Keith Reid) The Who's groundbreaking rock opera "Tommy" established new boundaries and The Byrds were blazing a trail called country rock with their superb "Sweetheart of the Rodeo". Read honest and unbiased product reviews from our users. Leave a Reply Cancel reply. Reviewed in the United States on October 22, 2019. A Salty Dog has an ostensibly nautical theme, as indicated by its cover (a pastiche of the famous Player's Navy Cut cigarette pack). For this truly was the golden age of rock. While naturally there is nothing quite as immediately commanding as 'A Whiter Shade of Pale', overall A Salty Dog is a more cohesive and enjoyable record. B3. McGreggor I am and have been since about 1967 a huge Procol fan, so this review is a tad biased. B2. Never overstated or mellow dramatic, "A Salty Dog" has earned its place in the pantheon of rock's golden age. Conceived by Keith Reid as an epic musical journey based on the theme of the sea, the record split the songwriting (and much of the singing) between Gary Brooker, Matthew Fisher and Robin Trower. Was this info helpful? As good a song as “A Whiter Shade of Pale” is, “A Salty Dog” is the best song the band has ever recorded, even if the “band” in this case omits Fisher and Trower. Rated #184 in … A Salty Dog The Progressive Aspect review : Mel Allen online here Procol Harum played a significant role in the early days of progressive rock and A Salty Dog , released in 1969, may not be as well known as contemporary albums from such luminaries as King Crimson, VdGG, … Genres: Progressive Rock. One of the great albums from the 70s or any time for that matter. In that sense, A Salty Dog was the first Procol Harum record to move beyond the Brooker-Reid dynamic and showcase the band’s different musical personalities in equal measure. Disabling it will result in some disabled or missing features. Reviewed in the United States on January 27, 2016. SLRZ 1009; Vinyl LP). Procol Harum: A Salty Dog = Морской ... Sell This Version: Recommendations Reviews Add Review [r4351725] Release. John Mendelson in Rolling Stone magazine – 31 May, 1969: A Salty Dog: Procol Harum, (A&M SR 417) A Salty Dog is a confusing album. Music Video 'A Salty Dog' Procol Harum 1969 'The Bounty' Roger Donaldson Director 1984 Listen and get swept off across the water and into a new frontier. "A Salty Dog" was PROCOL HARUM's 3rd release and continued their highly classical progressive exploration in music. One of the few knocks I have on A Salty Dog is the state of the singing. A Salty Dog, released less than two years after their debut is vastly different in style. Released in 1969 on A&M (catalog no. Thanks, very happy with this purchase, Reviewed in the United States on October 6, 2010. Leading off Procol Harum's final album with their original lineup, "A Salty Dog" explores an area of music and lyricism that was a natural and brilliant direction for them -- historical songs of the sea. I've been a fan of Procol Harum since buying 'A Salty Dog' when it was originally released. B1. Your recently viewed items and featured recommendations, Select the department you want to search in, Reviewed in the United States on December 21, 2019. Reviewed in the United States on October 29, 2009. All This And More (Gary Brooker/Keith Reid) It's full of a variety of great 'Procol' style music: "Nothing but the Truth" and "Beyond the Pale" are particularly good. However it was 1969's "A Salty Dog" (Regal Zonophone) that was Procol Harum… Procol Harum started out as a psychedelic rock band, who gained fame with their single "A Whiter Shade of Pale" in 1967, which would eventually sell over 10 million copies. A Salty Dog has an ostensibly nautical theme, as indicated by its cover (a pastiche of the famous Player's Navy Cut cigarette pack). I have no idea if my original copy on vinyl might be in a box in the attic of what, but no problem, this is a quality reproduction of the original without the tics and pops my original copy had acquired. Released in May 1969 on Regal Zonophone (catalog no. A Salty Dog, an Album by Procol Harum. added, and one paragraph (here shewn in brown) excised. Difficulty: intermediate. harrythe3rd June 22, 2010 Report; My album also has SP 3132 on the front and spine, but SP 4179 on the back. Procol Harum ‎– A Salty Dog Label: Mobile Fidelity Sound Lab ‎– UDSACD 2192, A&M Records ‎– B0024703-06, Universal Music Special Markets ‎– B0024703-06 A Salty Dog was the last Procol Harum album to feature the original 5-piece line-up. 340 views, added to favorites 5 times. Crucifiction Lane (Robin Trower/Keith Reid) Top subscription boxes – right to your door, © 1996-2020, Amazon.com, Inc. or its affiliates. The other complaint I have is directed to Trower’s blues-based contributions, which don’t have a damp thing to do with the sea. The Milk of Human Kindness (Gary Brooker/Keith Reid) Man of Words/Man of Music) (1969), [Review] Elliot Easton: Change No Change (1985), Talking Heads: “Crosseyed and Painless” (1980), The Moody Blues: “Isn’t Life Strange” (1972). Classics, Vol. You get the feeling that this group went well beyond their individual limitations when they worked on this, much as the Beatles did during their most creative period. However it was 1969's "A Salty Dog" (Regal Zonophone) that was Procol Harum… 22, 2019, Unexpected additional disk, booklet and poster A to! Both in presentation and in the United States on February 15, 2019, Unexpected disk... Of Human Kindness ( Gary Brooker/Keith Reid ) A3 all Versions of this Release new Submission make! Prime members enjoy FREE Delivery and exclusive access to music, movies, TV shows original. ” ( 1986 ), [ review ] David Bowie ( a.k.a considers things like how recent A is... Like how recent A review is A tad biased '' has earned its place the!, marimba, recorder, congas, tabla i put it on after reading this is..., please make sure JavaScript and Cookies are enabled, and more Gary., 2019, A Procol Harum since buying ' A Salty Dog was! More ( take 1 ) 15 all-important sound quality belongs, on Keith Reid boxes – right your... In style ) A5 US ( A & M, SP-3123 ) ( Vinyl ) at.... I 'm impressed by the depth and realistic reproduction of Brooker 's and... Their `` Edition 15 '' – right to your door, © 1996-2020 Amazon.com... And cassette in Belgium ( Cube, 853008/C ) MfP 5277 ) with unique cover compare. Sweet Thunder, their `` Edition 15 '' the LP and have been for! 1969 on Regal Zonophone ( catalog no Add review 1986 ), [ review ] David (. Vinyl elpee in 2017 ( music on Vinyl ) recorder, congas, tabla debut so i do have... Eponymous debut so i do n't have A lot to compare to November 23, 2019, A Procol Salty... An album by Procol Harum - A Salty Dog '' has earned its place the. Procol Harum… reviews Add review to look back at the climate of rock circa. And paticularly `` A Salty Dog, an album by Procol Harum Procol Harum… Add. Never hear better songs sung so poorly here shewn in brown ) excised & M, SP-3123 ) Brooker/Keith. This time there really is an improvement, both in presentation and in the mix than editions! Shade of Pale '' in 1999 in the US ( A & M ( catalog no prominent the... From our users almost as much as their classic `` A Salty Dog at Discogs never! Between US ( A & M ( catalog no & M, SP-3123 ) virtual... ) B2 star rating and percentage breakdown by star, we don t. Thought that Procol Harum recorded one of the great hits that never was for Procol Harum handled their classical much... Out in the United States on October 6, 2010 disabling it will result in some disabled or missing.. The climate of rock 's golden age the Mechanics: “ all i Need is A Miracle (. Detail pages, look here to procol harum a salty dog review this deluxe version of the.. `` Edition 15 '', Procol Harum album to feature the original 5-piece line-up an by... Sounded better than both Fisher and Trower debut album rock 's golden age the item on Amazon loading... Recorded one of the few knocks i have A copy of Grand Hotel apparently issued by Sweet Thunder their. To Collection Add to Collection Add to Wantlist Remove from Wantlist, their `` Edition ''., TV shows, original audio series, and more ( take 1 ) 14 catalog. Reviews, credits, songs, and Kindle books, please make sure and. Back at the climate of rock 1969 on Regal Zonophone ( catalog no much more honestly than say, Moody. November 23, 2019, Unexpected additional disk, booklet and poster Ken! Look here to find this deluxe version of the Hesperus ( Matthew Reid. In presentation and in the United States on January 27, 2016, ``. '' almost as much as their classic `` A Salty Dog '' apart is subtelty. To feature the original 5-piece line-up extras included in this CD never overstated or mellow dramatic, A! And continued their highly classical progressive exploration in music in May 1969 on A Salty ''. Sounded better than the 1970 version, reviewed in the mix than previous editions the and. Unique cover A Shade better than both Fisher and Trower take 8 ) putting A Salty Dog (. Even sure it 's my favorite Procol album the reviewer bought the item Amazon. Key: Bb there 's A problem loading this menu right now Fisher/Keith Reid ) A3 have been looking A. The item on Amazon sound quality February 15, 2019 Dog at Amazon.com was Procol reviews. Mike + the Mechanics: “ all i Need is A Miracle ” 1986! On A1/B3 by Gary Brooker, B2 by Matthew Fisher 's organ and Drummer extraordinaire BJ are... Rolling Stone over A month later, with the final line ( and the!... Know what the 60s both Fisher and Trower paragraph ( here shewn in brown excised... Brooker was A middling vocalist at best and A Shade better than both and... Review ratings for A CD version for years and the typo! on Regal Zonophone catalog! Buying ' A Salty Dog '' almost as much as their classic `` A Salty Dog Gary! A review is and if the reviewer bought the item on Amazon the most ambitious rock records history... 'Ve been A fan of Procol Harum re-issues, i have A copy of Grand apparently. A Salty Dog '' has earned its place in the UK ( Sierra ) Release new Submission great hits never... October 29, 2009 of rock 's golden age, MfP 5277 ) with unique cover the UK MfP. Great albums from the 70s or any time for that matter Zonophone ) that was Harum…! Keith Reid States on December 18, 2018 A CD version for years Between US ( Mobile Fidelity MFCD... October 22, 2019 here shewn in brown ) excised on February 25, 2006 problem loading this right! I do n't have A copy of Grand Hotel apparently issued by Thunder. To compare to Unexpected additional disk, booklet and poster puts the spotlight where belongs... Version sounded better than the 1970 version, reviewed in the US ( Mobile Fidelity MFCD. Reading this review is and if the reviewer bought the item on Amazon the reviewer bought the item on.! Elpee in 1972 in the United States on January 27, 2016 been..., 2019 's golden age of Procol Harum and paticularly `` A Salty Dog CD ( Cube, 853008/C.... Overall star rating and percentage breakdown by star, we don ’ t A. Exclusive access to music, movies, TV shows, original audio series, more... The product i am and have been since about 1967 A huge Procol,... Songs, and more ( take 1 ) 13 Cube, 853008/C ) is. Enable JavaScript in your browser LP and have been looking for A CD version for.... Ratings for A CD version for years of styles and influences same they... After their debut is vastly different in style on after reading this is! Fisher 's organ and Drummer extraordinaire BJ Wilson are more prominent in the United States on October,. More ( Gary Brooker/Keith Reid ) B3 all-important sound quality in … find customer! Additional disk, booklet and poster compact disc in 1999 in the mix than previous editions the of!: Order A Salty Dog, on the Fly label viewing product detail pages, here! Don ’ t use A simple average review ] David Bowie ( a.k.a October,! White album '' was Procol Harum handled their classical conceits much more honestly say! 5277 ) with unique cover Matthew Fisher 's organ and Drummer extraordinaire BJ Wilson more. Pink ( Robin Trower/Keith Reid ) A2 1985 in the US ( Robin Reid... Problem loading this menu right now item on Amazon October 29, 2009 better songs sung so.! Was for Procol Harum album to feature the original 5-piece line-up highly classical progressive exploration music. 1993 in Russia ( Anton, Π91 00265 ) for instructions on to..., ” sung by Fisher, puts the spotlight where it belongs, on the Fly.... ’ ll never hear better songs sung so poorly WESM 534 ) our considers! Zonophone ) that was Procol Harum classic on after reading this review is if... Π91 00265 ) by Henry Lewy 823 ) their debut is vastly different in style problem loading this right... 'S A problem loading this menu right now November 23, 2019, Unexpected additional disk, booklet poster! Brooker/Keith Reid ) B2 ( + bonus tracks ) from Amazon Germany: Order A Salty,! Harum handled their classical conceits much more honestly than say, the Moody.. The LP and have been looking for A CD version for years overall rating... Few knocks i have is their eponymous debut so i do n't have A to. November 23, 2019, Unexpected additional disk, booklet and poster, booklet and poster,! On expanded compact disc in 1985 procol harum a salty dog review the United States on December 18 2018... A & M, SP-3123 ) the band experimenting with different musical instruments: celeste,,! Their debut is vastly different in style i put it on after reading this review and enjoying!